Yokohama Advan Sport V107 vs Michelin Pilot Sport 5: In the realm of high-performance tires, few names command as much respect as Yokohama and Michelin. Automotive enthusiasts eagerly await the latest innovations in tire technology, and two models have emerged as the center of attention: the Yokohama Advan Sport V107 and the Michelin Pilot Sport 5. Launched in 2018, the Yokohama Advan Sport V107 is designed to offer exceptional wet and dry grip, a comfortable ride, and increased durability. On the other hand, the Michelin Pilot Sport 5, which was introduced in mid 2022, has already made its mark by winning numerous press tests it has participated in.
Both tires are engineered to deliver outstanding performance, safety, and driving enjoyment. The Yokohama Advan Sport V107 features a new silica compound and an asymmetric tread pattern that work in tandem to optimize grip, wear resistance, and fuel efficiency. In contrast, the Michelin Pilot Sport 5 is characterized by its enhanced spirited driving that lasts for more miles, providing an exhilarating and responsive driving experience with high performance and extended longevity. Furthermore, the Michelin Pilot Sport 5 allows drivers to command the road confidently with its long-lasting tire grip. The Dual Sport Tread Design has an internal side with large longitudinal grooves for superior wet road traction and an external side with rigid blocks for improved grip on dry roads. As a result, drivers can enjoy a fun and confident driving experience.
As the battle between these two high-performance tires intensifies, car enthusiasts and industry professionals will be keeping a close eye on which tire ultimately emerges as the victor. With the Michelin Pilot Sport 5 already amassing multiple accolades, it is clear that the tire industry is witnessing an exciting showdown. Let’s put these 2 tires against each other and see who comes out on top !
Table of Contents
New Feature Highlights:
Michelin Pilot Sport 5: Enhanced spirited driving that lasts for more miles
The Michelin Pilot Sport 5 tire offers a thrilling and responsive driving experience with high performance and increased longevity. It provides optimum responsiveness of steering instructions to the road with the use of Michelin Dynamic Response Technology. The MaxTouch Construction evenly distributes the forces of acceleration, braking, and cornering, providing a longer tread life and allowing for extended periods of high-performance driving.
Michelin Pilot Sport 5: Command the road confidently with long-lasting tire grip
The Michelin Pilot Sport 5 tire provides maximum grip and reliable wet and dry braking, allowing drivers to confidently command the road. The Dual Sport Tread Design features an internal side with large longitudinal grooves that flush water away for better wet road traction, as well as an external side with rigid blocks for improved grip on dry roads. With this tire, drivers can enjoy a fun and confident driving experience.
Results
Results below were taken from the 2023 AutoBild UHP Summer Test while includes an amazing 50 tires from its preliminary braking rounds. Only 20 tires made it through to the final round and a full detail evaluation was completed with these 20 tires. The wet & dry handling performances are evaluated objectively using the average lap speed rather than the preferred subjective ratings.
The graph above shows the comparison between Yokohama Advan Sport V107 vs Michelin Pilot Sport 5 based on the relevant performance category. The Yokohama Advan Sport V107 was set as a reference hence at the 100% mark. The tire size of interest is 225/45 R18 which is a common tire size for Mercedes-Benz C 200 and Kia Stinger . You can check out our latest tire size table for more information.
Wet
Safety has consistently been the primary focus when it comes to the necessity for wet performance. In damp conditions, both the Yokohama Advan Sport V107 and the Michelin Pilot Sport 5 provide exceptional braking capabilities. With both tires receiving an “A” rating in the EU wet label category, the only method to distinguish their wet braking performance is through testing. According to the test results, the Advan Sport V107 registered a braking distance of 39.7 meters from 80 km/h, while the Pilot Sport 5 reported a slightly longer distance of 40.6 meters at the same speed. Despite a difference of 0.9 meters, both tires ranked 5th and 7th out of the 50 tires tested, respectively. These findings demonstrate that both tires perform admirably in wet conditions, delivering excellent grip and traction.
The competition was much tighter in terms of wet handling, with the Pilot Sport 5 narrowly surpassing the Advan Sport V107, achieving an average lap speed of 75.5 km/h compared to the Advan Sport V107’s 75 km/h. A similar trend was observed in aquaplaning performance, where the Pilot Sport 5 took the lead with a higher slip speed of 105.7 km/h, compared to the 103 km/h reached by the Advan Sport V107. In lateral aquaplaning as well, the Pilot Sport 5 held a +0.15 m/s2 advantage over the Advan Sport V107. In summary, both tires excel in different areas, with the Advan Sport V107 demonstrating a distinct advantage in wet braking, while the Pilot Sport 5 excels in aquaplaning performance.
Pilot Sport 5:
- -2.2% in wet braking
- +0.7% in wet handling (lap speed)
- +2.6% in straight aquaplaning
- +4.1% in curved aquaplaning
Dry
In dry conditions, the Pilot Sport 5 demonstrates marginally superior braking performance compared to the Advan Sport V107. According to the test results, the Pilot Sport 5 registered a braking distance of 34.1 meters from 100 km/h, while the Advan Sport V107 posted a slightly shorter distance of 33.5 meters at the same speed. The minor difference of 0.6 meters is incredibly close, often leading to a photo finish. Similar to the wet braking outcomes, both tires rank in the top 10, with the Advan Sport V107 placing 3rd and the Pilot Sport 5 finishing 8th out of the 48 other tires evaluated.
This trend persists in dry handling, as the Advan Sport V107 achieves a higher average lap speed of 120.1 km/h compared to the 119.1 km/h recorded by the Pilot Sport 5. In summary, the Advan Sport V107 exhibits a marginally superior performance in dry conditions when compared to the Pilot Sport 5.
Pilot Sport 5:
- -1.8% in dry braking
- -0.8% in dry handling
Noise
The exterior noise generated by tires is an important factor to consider, as it can impact the overall driving experience and contribute to noise pollution. In this regard, the Advan Sport V107 outperformed the Pilot Sport 5 by a small margin. Test results showed that the Advan Sport V107 was 0.2 dB quieter than the Pilot Sport 5, offering a slightly more comfortable and serene driving environment.
However, it is worth noting that both tires ranked in the lower end of the competition when it comes to exterior noise levels. This suggests that while the Advan Sport V107 holds a minor advantage over the Pilot Sport 5 in terms of noise reduction, there may be other tires in the market that offer a more significant improvement in this area.
Drivers who prioritize a quiet and smooth ride may want to consider these findings when making their decision. Nonetheless, the noise difference between the Advan Sport V107 and Pilot Sport 5 is relatively small, and both tires still deliver exceptional performance in other critical aspects, such as handling, braking, and grip in various weather conditions. As a result, the ultimate choice will depend on the individual’s preferences and priorities when evaluating the balance between performance and comfort.
Pilot Sport 5:
- -0.3% in exterior noise (-0.2 dB)
Rolling Resistance
In the realm of ultra-high-performance tires, rolling resistance might not be the foremost concern for consumers making a purchase. However, with sustainability becoming an increasingly prominent topic, it’s beneficial to understand how these tires compare in this regard. For the first time in this head-to-head evaluation, we see a distinct difference between the two contenders. The Pilot Sport 5 boasts a considerably lower rolling resistance coefficient, registering at 8.09 N/kN compared to the Advan Sport V107’s 9.99 N/kN.
Lower rolling resistance can contribute to improved fuel efficiency and reduced CO2 emissions, making the Pilot Sport 5 a more environmentally friendly choice in this aspect. This difference could be a decisive factor for drivers who value both performance and sustainability when selecting their tires. While the Advan Sport V107 may excel in other areas, the Pilot Sport 5’s lower rolling resistance offers a notable advantage for those concerned with minimizing their ecological footprint without compromising on driving dynamics.
Pilot Sport 5:
- +23.5% in rolling resistance
Wear
As previously mentioned, mileage tests are quite uncommon, and we appreciate Auto Bild’s decision to conduct such a test for all 20 tires that advanced to the second round. The Pilot Sport 5 secured second place in the mileage test, boasting a projected mileage of 55,600 KM, which is significantly higher than the Advan Sport V107’s result of 33,600 KM, placing it fifth from last. This difference of 22,000 KM is substantial from our perspective.
Evidently, Michelin’s Pilot Sport 5 demonstrates exceptional prowess in balancing performance objectives, excelling in both wet braking and mileage ratings. This level of expertise cannot be attributed to the Advan Sport V107 in the same manner. The considerable difference in projected mileage showcases the Michelin Pilot Sport 5’s superior ability to provide long-lasting performance without sacrificing other essential aspects such as wet braking. In turn, this makes the Pilot Sport 5 a more attractive option for drivers seeking a high-performance tire that offers extended durability and top-tier performance.
Pilot Sport 5:
- +65.5% in mileage
Price
As the de facto technology leader in the tire industry, Michelin has built a reputation for producing high-quality, cutting-edge products that often come with a premium price tag. The Pilot Sport 5 exemplifies this trend, as it costs €38 more than the Yokohama Advan Sport V107. The higher price can be attributed to Michelin’s relentless dedication to research and development, which enables the company to incorporate advanced features and technologies that elevate performance, safety, and durability across their tire lineup.
The Pilot Sport 5 showcases Michelin’s ability to balance multiple performance aspects, such as wet braking, mileage, rolling resistance, and handling. The superior features of the Pilot Sport 5 justify the higher price for drivers seeking top-quality tires that deliver extended performance, excellent handling, and an overall satisfying driving experience.
Tire size: 225/45 R18
Pilot Sport 5 : €170
Yokohama Advan Sport V107: €132
Difference: +22% more expensive for Pilot Sport 5.
Summary
In conclusion, the Michelin Pilot Sport 5 emerges as the winner in this head-to-head comparison with the Yokohama Advan Sport V107. The Pilot Sport 5’s outstanding balance of performance in various aspects, including wet braking, handling, and rolling resistance, sets it apart as a superior choice for drivers seeking high-performance tires. Additionally, the Pilot Sport 5’s impressive wear and extended mileage contribute to its exceptional value proposition.
While the Yokohama Advan Sport V107 also offers commendable capabilities, it falls short in critical areas such as wear and rolling resistance when compared to the Pilot Sport 5. Michelin has demonstrated its expertise in designing a tire that excels in multiple areas without compromising on key factors like longevity and sustainability.