Best Tires for Tesla Model Y : The Tesla Model Y, launched in March 2020, has taken the automotive world by storm with its sleek design, remarkable range, and advanced features. As a groundbreaking addition to Tesla’s lineup of electric vehicles, the Model Y has quickly become a favorite among EV enthusiasts and eco-conscious drivers alike (Tesla, 2020).
This compact SUV boasts impressive features such as the Full Self-Driving (FSD) capability, Tesla’s Autopilot system, and a panoramic glass roof that offers a spacious feel while providing excellent protection from solar radiation. Additionally, the Model Y showcases a generous cargo space, seating for up to seven passengers, and an estimated range of up to 326 miles (EPA) on a single charge.
To enhance the performance and efficiency of this electric powerhouse, selecting the right tires is crucial. The Tesla Model Y can accommodate tire sizes 255/45R19, 255/40R20, 255/35R21 and 275/35R21. In this guide, we will explore the best tire options available for the Model Y to ensure optimal handling, safety, and energy efficiency. Stay tuned as we dive into the world of high-performance tires, designed specifically for your Tesla Model Y.
Table of Contents
Original Equipment Tires for Tesla Model Y
When purchasing a new Tesla Model Y, the car comes equipped with either 19″, 20″, or 21″ tires, depending on the chosen specification. These tires are supplied by different manufacturers, which we will discuss individually below. It’s important to note that these are all summer tires, and depending on your location, all-season or winter tires may be more suitable for your needs.
| Tire Size | Location | Size |
|---|---|---|
| 19″ | Front/Rear | 255/45R19 XL |
| 20″ | Front/Rear | 255/40R20 XL |
| 21″ | Front | 255/35R21 XL |
| 21″ | Rear | 275/35R21 XL |
19″ Hankook Ventus S1 evo 3 – 255/45R19 XL
- Ventus S1 evo 3
- Launch: 2020
- Press test wins: –
- Strength: Extremely strong wet braking
Check out our head to head comparison of Ventus S1 evo 3 against its competitors.
Ventus S1 evo 3
Price
- 255/45R19 : $283
20″ Michelin Pilot Sport EV – 255/40R20 XL
- Pilot Sport EV
- Launch: 2021
- Press test wins: –
- Strength: Good rolling resistance & cornering stiffness
Check out our head to head comparison of Pilot Sport EV against its competitors.
Pilot Sport EV
Price
- 255/40R20 : $365
21″ Pirelli P Zero (PZ4) – 255/35R21 XL // 275/35R21 XL
- P Zero (PZ4)
- Launch: 2016
- Press test wins: 3/24
- Strength: Strong in dry handling
Check out our head to head comparison of P Zero (PZ4) against its competitors.
P Zero (PZ4)
Price
The Tesla Model Y comes equipped with OE tires specifically designed to optimize performance and efficiency. For the 19-inch wheels, the Hankook Ventus S1 evo 3 – 255/45R19 XL tires are fitted, offering exceptional wet braking capabilities. The 20-inch variant features the Michelin Pilot Sport EV – 255/40R20 XL tires, which excel in rolling resistance and cornering stiffness, ensuring a smooth and confident ride. Lastly, the 21-inch option utilizes Pirelli P Zero (PZ4) tires, with sizes 255/35R21 XL and 275/35R21 XL, delivering impressive dry handling performance. Each tire option is carefully selected to provide the best driving experience while maintaining the efficiency and safety that Tesla is known for.
To gain insight into how well the original equipment (OE) tires perform against their replacement counterparts, feel free to check out our Tesla Model 3 OE vs. replacement comparison featuring both Continental and Michelin OE tires. Additionally, we conducted a Tesla Model S tire showdown featuring the upcoming Hankook EV tire “iON evo,” Michelin Pilot Sport 5 (replacement summer), and Michelin Pilot Sport 3 (OE). Be sure to check it out to get a feeling on the OE (factory tire) vs standard summer vs EV tire,
Replacement Tires for Tesla Model Y
3 Peak Mountain
As mentioned in our best 225/65R17 tire article, all season tires have always been the go to tires for the American market and this segment has been well established across the years. There are 2 types of all season tires, one with 3 peak mountain & one with only M+S. We have covered these 2 types of tire head to head with Michelin Defender T+H (M+S) vs Cross Climate 2 (3 peak mountain) and the M+S all season tires usually are worst in winter performances but excel much better in mileage.
If you are in an area which snows quite heavily, 3 peak mountain all season tires would be definitely a good choice. However if you have very light snow or in areas where temperatures do not drop below 45°F (7°C), a standard all season tire with M+S logo would be sufficient. If you fancy a much more handling dominant tire, the ultra high performance all season segment would fit perfectly.
While the OE tires on the Model Y are designed to meet the needs of the vehicle, many owners may choose to replace their tires with different options to better suit their driving preferences or conditions. Below are some of the best tires for Tesla Model Y based on the discussed segmentation :
All Season tires (3 Peak Mountain)
1. Michelin Cross Climate 2
Michelin once again demonstrated its innovative prowess by revolutionizing the all-season tire segment with the highly successful 3-peak mountain snowflake-certified CrossClimate in 2015. At that time, the all-season tire market was predominantly focused in America, with most offerings exhibiting poor winter performance. The CrossClimate proved that it was possible to achieve only a slight compromise in summer performance while dominating in winter conditions. Following the initial success of the CrossClimate, every tire manufacturer scrambled to launch their own competing products, but none have managed to strike the same balance as the latest CrossClimate 2.
Upon our initial review, the Michelin CrossClimate 2 is the only 3-peak mountain snowflake-certified all-season tire available for the Model Y. With its outstanding performance in both winter and summer conditions, the Michelin CrossClimate 2 is undoubtedly the top choice for those seeking a reliable 3-peak mountain snowflake all-season tire.
- Cross Climate 2
- Launch: 2020
- Press test wins: 3/6
- Strength: Well balance summer & winter performances. Excellent wear.
Check out our head to head comparison of Cross Climate 2 against its competitors.
Cross Climate 2 vs
- Bridgestone Weather Control A005 EVO
- Bridgestone Alenza AS Ultra
- Bridgestone Turanza QuietTrack
- Bridgestone WeatherPeak
- Continental PureContact LS
- Continental AllSeasonContact
- Continental Cross Contact LX25
- Goodyear Vector 4Seasons Gen-3
- Goodyear Assurance ComfortDrive
- Michelin Cross Climate+
- Michelin Defender T+H
- Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4
- Pirelli Cinturato All Season SF2
- Pirelli Scorpion AS Plus 3
- Vredestein Quatrac Pro
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $310
All Season tires (M+S)
Before the invention of the snowflake capable tires, all season tires mostly carried the M+S logo which means mountain & snow. The M+S logo does not require you to pass any test hence it is up to the manufacturer to determine its usage. This segment provides some light snow usage capability but its main focus is on mileage. This is also one of the main reasons that the products generally do not perform well in wet. Below are the best tires for Tesla Model Y for the all season M+S segment
1. Continental PureContact LS
The Continental PureContact LS, launched in 2018, has made a name for itself in the tire industry for its outstanding wet and dry performance. Designed to provide a comfortable and fuel-efficient ride, these tires excel in providing excellent grip and handling on both wet and dry surfaces. However, despite their many benefits, the PureContact LS tires have been noted to show weaker performance in winter conditions. Drivers in colder climates or those who experience significant snowfall should take this into consideration when selecting tires for their vehicle.
- PureContact LS
- Launch: 2018
- Press test wins: 0/1
- Strength: Wet & dry
Check out our head to head comparison of PureContact LS against its competitors.
PureContact LS vs
- Continental ProContact RX T1
- Goodyear Assurance WeatherReady
- Bridgestone WeatherPeak
- Michelin Cross Climate 2
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $273
2. Bridgestone Turanza QuietTrack
The Bridgestone Turanza QuietTrack, launched in 2019, has gained recognition for its well-rounded performance, particularly in winter conditions. With excellent steering feel, the Turanza QuietTrack provides drivers with confidence and control, even in colder climates. However, there is some room for improvement, as the tires could benefit from increased composure at the limit of grip. Despite these minor shortcomings, the Turanza QuietTrack has established itself as a benchmark in the tire industry, although it does face stiff competition from other high-performing tire models.
- Turanza QuietTrack
- Launch: 2019
- Press test wins: 0/1
- Strength: Noise & comfort
Check out our head to head comparison of Turanza QuietTrack against its competitors.
Turanza QuietTrack vs
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $290
3. General AltiMAX RT45
General’s AltiMAX RT45 was launched this year in 2022 and covers mostly passenger cars, minivans, SUVs and crossovers sizes. AltiMAX RT45 was designed and sold specifically in the North American market. This is the general commitment from General’s research & development approach of bringing the best products for the local market. Based on the test results, AltiMAX RT45 had good wet braking but had a higher noise level compared to other tires.
- AltiMAX RT45
- Launch: 2022
- Press test wins: 0/1
- Strength: Strong wet.
Check out our head to head comparison of AltiMAX RT45 against its competitors.
AltiMAX RT45 vs
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $197
Ultra High Performance All Season tires
Ultra high performance all season tires are designed to provide exceptional handling, grip, and speed while also being suitable for use in a wide range of weather conditions. These tires are ideal for drivers who want a high level of performance and responsiveness in their vehicle, but also need a tire that can handle light snow or rain. Ultra high performance all season tires feature a unique combination of technology and materials to provide excellent traction, durability, and comfort in a variety of driving situations.
1. Continental ExtremeContact DWS 06 Plus
ExtremeContact DWS 06 Plus was launched in 2021 to succeed the popular ExtremeContact DWS 06 with a compound upgrade which promised to deliver enhanced braking & handling performance. Based on the head to head results below, ExtremeContact DWS 06 Plus showed clear dominance on wet & dry surfaces while performing relatively well in winter performances. Surely a tire to consider before your next purchase !
- ExtremeContact DWS 06 Plus
- Launch: 2021
- Press test wins: 0/1
- Strength: Good wet & dry.
Check our head to head comparison of ExtremeContact DWS 06 Plus against its competitors.
ExtremeContact DWS 06 Plus vs
- Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus
- Bridgestone Potenza RE980AS+
- Goodyear Eagle Exhilarate
- Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4
- Continental ExtremeContact Sport
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $279
2. Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4
Similar to the other top competitors, Pilot Sport All Season 4 is a dedicated North America region tireline and it was launched in 2020 with sizes primarily above 16″ Based on the head to head comparison below, Pilot Sport All Season 4, excels in snow & and dry while slightly losses out in wet, comfort & ice. Overall Pilot Sport All Season 4 has a well rounded balance package.
- Pilot Sport All Season 4
- Launch: 2020
- Press test wins: 0/1
- Strength: Snow & dry.
Check our head to head comparison of Pilot Sport All Season 4 against its competitors.
Pilot Sport All Season 4 vs
- Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus
- Bridgestone Potenza RE980AS+
- Goodyear Eagle Exhilarate
- Continental ExtremeContact DWS 06 Plus
- Michelin Cross Climate 2
- Michelin Pilot Sport 4S
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $309
3. Pirelli P Zero All Season Plus
Pirelli’s P Zero All Season Plus is a dedicated region tireline specific to the North America market. It was launched in 2016 and covers most of the 17-20″ popular sizes.. Based on the head to head comparison below, P Zero All Season Plus has strong showing in dry handling & noise but lacks the firepower in other areas.
- P Zero All Season Plus
- Launch: 2016
- Press test wins: 0/2
- Strength: Dry handling & noise.
Check our head to head comparison of P Zero All Season Plus against its competitors.
P Zero All Season Plus vs
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $312
Max Performance Summer tires
Introducing the Max Performance Summer tire segment, designed specifically for regions where winter is non-existent and warm temperatures prevail throughout the year. In these climates, the primary focus is on achieving superior dry handling and the best wet braking capabilities to ensure safety and performance in varying road conditions. Max Performance Summer tires combine cutting-edge technology and advanced materials to deliver outstanding grip, precise steering response, and impressive stability. These tires cater to drivers who demand the ultimate in handling and braking performance, without the need to consider winter weather challenges. Experience the thrill of driving with confidence and control in a warm climate with the Max Performance Summer tire segment.
1. Michelin Pilot Super Sport
Although this tire may be relatively older compared to some recent offerings, it continues to hold its own in today’s competitive market. The Pilot Super Sport is designed to deliver exceptional handling, grip, and durability, making it a popular choice for performance-oriented drivers. By utilizing cutting-edge technology and Michelin’s extensive experience, the Pilot Super Sport offers a remarkable balance of performance and longevity, proving that age is just a number when it comes to top-tier tires.
- Pilot Super Sport
- Launch: 2010
- Press test wins: 1/1
- Strength: Good dry handling.
Check our head to head comparison of Pilot Super Sport against its competitors.
Pilot Super Sport vs
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $367
2. Bridgestone Potenza Sport
Bridgestone Potenza Sport was recently launched in 2021 with the hopes of competing with the likes of Michelin’s Pilot Sport 4S. Based on the head to head results, Potenza Sport lacks the fire power in both wet & dry compartment with a glimmer of hope with great subjective wet handling.
- Potenza Sport
- Launch: 2021
- Press test wins: 1/12
- Strength: Wet handling.
Check our head to head comparison of Potenza Sport against its competitors.
Potenza Sport vs
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $269
3. Pirelli P Zero (PZ4)
Introducing the versatile Pirelli P Zero (PZ4) tire, a high-performance option that delivers exceptional handling and control across various wheel sizes. While it is true that the PZ4 is an original equipment (OE) tire for the 21-inch Tesla Model Y, Pirelli has made this outstanding tire available in 19 and 20-inch sizes in the replacement market as well.
This expanded offering ensures that Tesla Model Y drivers, regardless of their wheel size, can benefit from the superior performance and quality that the Pirelli P Zero (PZ4) is known for. Experience unparalleled grip, handling, and responsiveness on the road with the Pirelli P Zero (PZ4), now accessible for all Tesla Model Y wheel configurations. Based on the head to head comparison below, P Zero excels in wet braking & rolling resistance while was weak in aquaplaning.
- P Zero
- Launch: 2016
- Press test wins: 3/17
- Strength: Wet braking & rolling resistance.
Check our head to head comparison of P Zero against its competitors.
P Zero vs
- Bridgestone Potenza Sport
- Continental ExtremeContact Sport
- Michelin Pilot Sport 4S
- Michelin Pilot Super Sport
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $404
Studless tires aka Snow tires
As we are talking about winter tires, it is very important to distinguish between the studless & winter segment. The studless segment has a main focus on ice & snow and it is currently the best tire selection for extreme cold weather conditions (<23°F). Winter tires are mainly focused on milder winter conditions (>23°F) while having a very strong wet braking performance. These are typically used in middle European countries as they do not have such cold winters.
For the American market, studless tires are the main go to tires when it comes to snow tires as the winter middle European tires are usually not sold directly here. Below are the best snow tires for Tesla Model Y for the American market.
1. Continental Viking Contact 7
Viking Contact 7 is Continental’s best performing tire in the press test with a win rate of 24 out of the 27 tests it has contested. With a clear strength in ice & snow performances while balancing the summer performances, Viking Contact 7 is clearly the best snow tire in the market !
- Viking Contact 7
- Launch: 2018
- Press test wins: 24/27
- Strength: Best in class in ice & snow. Weak in aquaplaning.
Check out our head to head comparison of Viking Contact 7 against its competitors.
Viking Contact 7 vs
- Continental WinterContact TS 860
- Goodyear UltraGrip Ice 2
- Michelin X-Ice Snow
- Nokian Hakkapeliitta R3
- Pirelli Ice Zero FR
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $279
2. Michelin X-Ice SNOW
Michelin’s answer towards Continental’s Viking Contact 7 is a new product called X-Ice Snow. This was a long awaited upgrade for 8 years as X-Ice Snow was launched in 2020. Based on the head to head results below, X-Ice Snow excels relatively good in Ice & Snow but lacks in wet performances.
- X-Ice Snow
- Launch: 2020
- Press test wins: 0/12
- Strength: Relatively good ice & snow.
Check our head to head comparison of X-Ice Snow against its competitors.
X-Ice Snow vs
- Continental Viking Contact 7
- Nokian Hakkapeliitta R3
- Pirelli Ice Zero FR
- Michelin Pilot Alpin 5
- Bridgestone Blizzak WS90
- Goodyear WinterCommand Ultra
- Michelin Cross Climate 2
- Michelin Pilot Sport All Season 4
Price
- 255/45 R19 : $322
Summary
In conclusion, selecting the best tires for your Tesla Model Y is crucial for optimizing performance, efficiency, and safety. It’s essential to choose the appropriate seasonal tire that best fits your specific needs, as different tires excel in various weather conditions and driving scenarios. The replacement market offers a vast array of excellent options, each with their unique strengths. When selecting the ideal tires for your Model Y, consider factors such as wet and dry handling, cornering stiffness, rolling resistance, and braking performance. Additionally, take into account your local climate, road conditions, and driving habits to ensure the most suitable tires are chosen. By making an informed decision, you can enhance your Tesla Model Y’s overall driving experience and ensure a safer, more enjoyable ride tailored to your individual preferences.