The Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 vs Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus is a heavyweight battle in the high-mileage all-season segment, where long tread life, everyday comfort, wet grip and value all matter. Both tires are built for drivers who want to go further without giving up confidence, but they take very different approaches to the same goal. Goodyear brings its mileage-focused Assurance formula, while Pirelli counters with the P4 Persist AS Plus and its reputation for long-lasting touring performance. So which one is the better tire to live with for the next 70,000 miles?
Table of Contents
Results: Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 vs Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus
The test results are based on Treadwell data from Discount Tire. The graph below compares the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 vs Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus across key performance categories.
For subjective evaluations, each point is treated as equivalent to a 5% difference. For example, if Tire A scores a 4 and Tire B scores a 3, Tire A is considered 5% better than Tire B in that category.
Wet
In wet braking, the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 stops 15 feet shorter than the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus, at 155 feet versus 170 feet, giving the Goodyear a 9% advantage. In wet handling, the Goodyear scores 4/5 compared with 2.5/5, a difference of 1.5 points, with the Pirelli rated 7.5% lower. Overall, the Goodyear is clearly stronger in the wet, with better braking and noticeably better handling.
P4 Persist AS Plus :
- -9% Wet Braking
- -7.5% Wet Handling
Winter
In winter performance, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus scores 3/5 compared with 2/5 for the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2, a difference of 1 point. Based on the relative test rating, the Pirelli performs 5% better. Overall, the Pirelli has the advantage in winter conditions, offering slightly stronger cold-weather capability.
P4 Persist AS Plus :
- +5% Snow
Mileage
In mileage, the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 lasts about 1,500 miles longer than the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus, at 51,000 miles versus 49,500 miles. Based on the relative test rating, the Pirelli delivers 3% less mileage. Overall, the difference is small, but the Goodyear has a slight advantage in tread life.
P4 Persist AS Plus :
- -3% Mileage
Dry
In dry braking, the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 stops 3 feet shorter than the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus, at 130 feet versus 133 feet, giving the Goodyear a 2% advantage. In dry handling, both tires score 3/5, so there is no performance difference between them. Overall, the Goodyear has a small edge in dry performance, mainly from its slightly shorter braking distance.
P4 Persist AS Plus :
- 2% Dry Braking
- 0% Dry Handling
Noise Vibration & Harshness (NVH)
For quietness, both tires score 3.5/5, so there is no difference in noise performance. In ride comfort, the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 scores 4/5 compared with 3/5 for the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus, a difference of 1 point, with the Pirelli rated 5% lower. Overall, both are equally quiet, but the Goodyear provides the more comfortable ride.
P4 Persist AS Plus :
- 0% Quiet Ride
- -5% Comfort
Fuel Consumption
In fuel efficiency, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus scores 2.5/5 compared with 2/5 for the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2, a difference of 0.5 points. Based on the relative test rating, the Pirelli is 2.5% better. Overall, the Pirelli has a small advantage in fuel efficiency.
P4 Persist AS Plus :
- +2.5% Fuel Efficiency
Price
For 215/55R17, the Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus costs $158 compared with $215 for the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2, making the Pirelli $57 cheaper per tire. That means the Pirelli is about 27% cheaper, while the Goodyear is about 36% more expensive. Overall, the Pirelli has a clear price advantage, especially when buying a full set.
Tire size: 215/55R17
- Assurance MaxLife 2: $215
- P4 Persist AS Plus : $158
Difference: -27% more cheaper for P4 Persist AS Plus
Conclusion:
From my perspective, the Goodyear Assurance MaxLife 2 is the stronger all-round tire, with clear advantages in wet braking, wet handling, ride comfort and a small edge in mileage and dry braking. The Pirelli P4 Persist AS Plus fights back with better winter performance, slightly better fuel efficiency and, most importantly, a much lower price. If I prioritize safety and overall performance, I would choose the Goodyear, but if value is the priority, the Pirelli makes a very strong case.
Dr Edwin Pang